Crude Oil Markets Caught Between Weak Refining Margins and Geopolitical Risks

Oil Market Faces Weakened Refining Margins and Slower Demand Growth

The global oil market has experienced notable turbulence in recent months, with key factors including a weaker-than-expected demand outlook and falling refining margins. As major economies grapple with economic uncertainty and sluggish growth, oil prices have struggled to maintain momentum. However, some bullish sentiment persists, supported by geopolitical factors and supply-side adjustments.

Impact of Fed’s Rate Cut on Oil Prices

One of the most significant drivers of oil price movements recently was the U.S. Federal Reserve's decision to cut interest rates by 0.5%. This aggressive monetary easing injected a temporary sense of optimism into the markets, pushing both WTI and Brent crude futures up. As of late September, WTI futures rallied to hover around $72 per barrel, while Brent gained roughly $2 over the week, nearing $74 per barrel.

The rate cut was widely seen as a move to stimulate economic growth, which could translate into stronger demand for crude oil. However, the market's response has been relatively subdued, with concerns that the rate cut may also reflect deeper economic issues that could dampen long-term oil demand growth. This tension between short-term optimism and long-term uncertainty has kept oil prices from breaking out more significantly.

Refining Margins Under Pressure Globally

The refining sector has been hit hard by weaker margins, particularly in Asia and Europe. Refining profits have slumped to multi-year lows, driven by a confluence of factors such as the end of the summer driving season, slower economic growth in China, and a wave of new refining capacity coming online in regions like the Middle East and Africa.

In Asia, refining margins fell to their lowest seasonal level since 2020, with reports suggesting that refiners in China may be forced to cut run rates in response. In Europe, refining margins have also been squeezed, with gasoline profit margins in August averaging just $12.10 per barrel—a 61% drop compared to the same period in 2023. Major refiners such as Repsol in Spain and Eni in Italy are reportedly considering reducing their production output to cope with the weak profitability environment.

U.S. refiners have not been spared either. Profits have fallen from the record highs seen in the previous two years, with diesel margins plummeting to their lowest since late 2021. In Singapore, Asia's refining hub, the complex refining margin indicator dropped to its weakest level for this time of year in three years, further highlighting the challenging environment for global refiners.

Geopolitical Risks Boost Oil Sentiment

Despite the bearish backdrop of weakening refining margins, oil prices have received support from escalating geopolitical tensions, particularly in the Middle East. Recent airstrikes by Israel on Hezbollah positions in southern Lebanon have heightened fears of broader regional conflict, which could disrupt oil supplies from the region. This geopolitical risk premium has provided some support to crude prices, even as market fundamentals point to a softening demand outlook.

In addition, a significant drawdown in U.S. crude oil inventories has also helped to buoy prices. According to the Energy Information Administration (EIA), U.S. crude stockpiles dropped to their lowest level in a year, with inventories standing at 417.5 million barrels. This reduction in supply, combined with tightening production quotas from OPEC+, has rekindled hopes of higher prices, at least in the short term.

China’s Struggling Economy Weighs on Oil Demand

China, the world's largest importer of crude oil, continues to play a pivotal role in shaping global oil demand trends. However, economic data from the country has been less than encouraging. Industrial output growth has slowed, and oil consumption remains subdued, exacerbating the downward pressure on refining margins and global oil prices.

In August, China's apparent oil demand was estimated at 12.5 million barrels per day, a 15% year-on-year decline. Chinese refiners have responded by cutting production and building inventories, with stockpiles rising by 3.2 million barrels per day, the largest monthly increase since 2015. At the same time, gasoline exports from China slumped by 44% in August, as export margins turned negative.

Two independent refiners in China, Zhenghe Group and Shandong Huaxing Petrochemical, recently declared bankruptcy, underscoring the severe strain on the sector. Meanwhile, another major refinery operated by Sinochem is expected to meet with creditors later this month as financial pressures mount.

OPEC+ Supply Cuts and the Future of Oil Prices

The OPEC+ group has been instrumental in stabilizing oil prices over the past few years through coordinated supply cuts. However, with demand growth stagnating and global inventories rising, the question remains whether the cartel will implement further production cuts to support prices. Some analysts believe that OPEC+ may begin unwinding current cuts in early 2025, as non-OPEC+ supply increases and the market potentially shifts into oversupply.

Despite this uncertainty, some investment banks, including Citi, have maintained a bearish outlook, forecasting oil prices to fall to $60 per barrel by 2025 unless additional production cuts are made. Goldman Sachs has similarly revised its price expectations downward, now predicting Brent to trade between $70 and $85 per barrel over the next year.

The market's bearish positioning has reached historic levels, with money managers holding a net short position in Brent crude for the first time on record. This extreme pessimism reflects widespread concerns over weak demand and falling refining margins, particularly in Europe and Asia. However, such extreme positioning could also set the stage for a short-covering rally if market sentiment shifts and demand shows signs of improvement.

Conclusion: Mixed Signals for Crude Oil

While the oil market faces significant headwinds in the form of weaker refining margins, slowing demand growth, and bearish market positioning, there are still pockets of bullish sentiment driven by geopolitical risks and supply-side constraints. The Fed's rate cut has provided a temporary boost, but longer-term demand concerns, particularly in China, continue to weigh on prices.

The outlook for oil remains mixed, with many analysts predicting continued volatility as the market grapples with competing forces of weak demand and potential supply disruptions. For investors, the key question is whether these factors will ultimately lead to sustained higher prices or whether the bearish sentiment will continue to dominate in the months ahead.

That's TradingNEWS